Goldberg, Sipping Wine

First thoughts on the second half of Writing Down the Bones, by Natalie Goldberg, starting with Sipping Wine. You can see my thoughts on the first half, which ended with Sipping Wine, in the post Goldberg, First Ideas.

In the class on Friday, 4/1/22, we did some journal writing. Most of the class read from their writing. I chose not to, my thoughts were still formulating. As I read this last half of Goldberg, I had 3 things from my Friday’s class notes on my mind:

  • Ekphrastic – the original meaning was “telling in full”. The more modern definition is “a self-contained description, often on 2 common place subjects, which can be inserted at a fitting place in discourse.”
  • Stone – the object I chose from Dr. Hudson’s office. A common place object, often overlooked, it is pulled from the earth. My stone is symbolically two common subjects linked metaphorically.
  • Window – A medium through which our mind transports us to another place.

I’m not explaining that well here, I had no chance of explaining it in class. I’ll occasionally make references to these.

Start of 2nd Half Review

I’m going to put page numbers where I found ideas that I feel are worthy of noting. I’m doing this for myself. I intend to return every so often and reread.

p. 72 Russell Edson emphasizes the importance of first sentences. Write these down, along with a short piece, return later. Maybe choose one to expand upon.
p. 74 Take chances. You’ll succeed only if you take chances

p. 75 Don’t Tell, but Show

p. 77 Be Specific

p. 82 {Window} using details to step through to the other shore

p. 84 Talk is a window to great material

p. 85 {Window} Talk about the ordinary can be a conduit to writing that is extraordinary simply in the telling.

p. 88 My blog can be one of the most basic, and effective, ways to self publish.

p. 89 {Window} become what it is you are seeing, express it in your writing

p. 90 As with an animal, move slowly, stalk your prey. This is how I naturally approach most of what I do. Let the writing percolate.

p. 98-102 There’s an art to choosing the right restaurants in which to write

p. 113 Write. When you’re done, write a little more.

p. 123 Hemingway. Not the why, but the what.

p. 133 I disagree with “write a lot of forms”. I say, write. Write without regard to what form it may be taking. When done, look to discover what form it has taken.

p. 139 I qualify what I just noted on p.133. I’m finding I’m grazing in different fields of writing. I don’t always like the taste, at least at first. I was further reminded of something Aunt Jean told me…

Aunt Jean – an excellent writer an avid reader – once told me that when she was first married she hated olives. Her mother-in-law told her, “if you eat 8 olives, you will love them for the rest of your life”. Aunt Jean choked down a couple, then a couple more, then… she loved them to her dying day.

p. 140-140 The chapter speaks to me. “Rules” are lost on me, I break them from the start. This song came to mind:
I drink when I’m hungry,
I eat when I’m dry
I’m always hungry and
I’m never dry.
Hallelujah, I’m a bum
Hallelujah, bum again
Hallelujah, give a handout and
Revive me again

p. 147 Food is a stone for me. Go to food when you cannot think of anything to write about. Food is filled with metaphor, as I look at my egg cooking, I see the morning sun breaking through fluffy white clouds. I have only to look at my Facebook posts, rarely a week goes by without posting about food.

p. 150 Loneliness is my window, transporting what’s inside my mind to the outside physical world around me.

p. 152-155 Going Home. In nearly all my writing, I find something from the time I can recall my very first memories thru the time I left home to go off to college.

Write sentences, or very short paragraphs, and stick those in notes. Better yet, in a private post. Review these from time to time, there’s a story there waiting to be told.

p. 159 Kathleen has us form a circle, every class becomes a “story circle”. Have a better awareness of this, record the stories that form from the images in my brain as I listen to my budding fellow student writers.

p. 164 Claim Your Writing

p. 167 Trust Yourself

p. 170 Alan Ginsberg was asked, “How come you don’t criticize work more?” His response was, “Why bother talking about something you don’t like?” I’ve received virtually no responses, not even very many simple “Likes” on my Facebook post to a link to my Short Story, A Woman Named Stephanie. I’m going to re-post that link and use Ginsberg’s quote as a possible reason I’ve had a paucity of responses.

p. 172-176 I made numerous revisions to my recent short story submission, after submission. A powerful tool, available to anyone posting online with WordPress, is the plugin Yoast SEO (I subscribe to Premium, but the basic is good and it’s free). Search Engine Optimization moves your post, and blog, up in Google rankings. Many, perhaps these days most or all, of what Google looks for is what publishers look for and what readers demand.

Goldberg says to look for what gives your work energy, makes it hot. These are the same things that ranks your work high among search engine rankings.

p. 177-178 I don’t want to die. I made a note, this last chapter is “worth re-reading”.

I’m going to do a very quick re-reading, then make this my submission. It will then be also available as a post on my blog. I intend to give this a day or two, then re-visit and pull perhaps the top 5 things from my above list.

Wm initials

Goldberg, First Ideas

Ideas from reading the first 75 pages of “Writing Down the Bones”, by Natalie Goldberg.

(1) Beginner’s Mind
When I do my Daily Calm meditation or yoga, the master often talks about beginner’s mind. We refer to our sessions as a practice, always striving to improve. If we start becoming complacent, assuming we have little to learn, we will in fact gain little. By resetting our mind, looking at our session as if for the first time, we will always find something fresh and stimulating.

Equanimity
Equanimity

(2) First Thoughts
Back in the days when was running regularly, somewhere around 20-30 minutes into my run, I would almost always get what runners often refer to as a second wind. Often times at the start of my runs I would have thoughts of quitting, making it short, a constant struggle. Long before I discovered yoga or meditation, I found setting my mind on my breath, counting my steps to 100, 1, 2, 3… 10, 1, 2 ,3… 20,… or smoothing my strides would cause my mind to get further and further along into my run. All of a sudden the second wind would occur. It was like a calming came over my entire body, in meditation I would refer to it as being in the present moment, equanimity.

(3) Practice Writing vs Writing Practice
Just as in the Beginner’s Mind thought, I prefer to think of writing as a practice. I’ve been trying to write all my bog entries first doing Writing Practice, using the approach actually described in First Thoughts. That is: not being concerned about spelling, grammar, punctuation; writing continuously; losing control; no stopping to edit in your mind; just write.

(4) Composting
You can always edit a bad page of writing, never a blank page. That actually came during Day 3 of class, a list of “tips for writing”, but it popped into my mind as I reviewed notes in the book.

(5) Artistic Stability
As I reviewed my notebook I’m keeping on “Writing Down the Bones”, I saw an entry “This page intentionally blank”. Apparently on first reading I didn’t find much to note. I read it again. This time I’ll note, “do not be afraid of the voices inside you”.

(6) A List of Topics for Writing Practice
On my blog I have a list that is growing quite long. My plan is to put links to the topics I actually write about. Actually, two links, one normally private, the “practice”, the other what I’m willing to share as my current offering. In the book I wrote idiosyncrasies, I have many.

(7) Fighting Tofu
Add flavorful sauce to your bland, but healthy, ‘tofu’ writing.

(8) Ideas for writing? What’s in front of you is a good start!

(9) Tap into what’s below the surface. It’s free and available for the taking.

(10) We are not the poem
What we have written came about at a moment in time. We are not what we write.

(11) Start your writing simple, exposing yourself in layers

(12) Obsessions
Make a list. {I’m thinking…}

(13) Original Detail
Doesn’t need to be where you found, include original detail. Use enough and you’re done. Be awake to the details around you.

Nora Ephron, by Hilary McHone
Nora Ephron, photo by Hilary McHone

This reminds me of something I have always done, no idea if it’s just one of my many quirks, or if everyone does this. I might stand in front of something, let’s say the Mona Lisa. Everyone looks at the smile, right? Not so for me, I find myself looking at the background. What is it? Mountains? A lake, a stream, a footbridge across a stream? Why did Da Vinci do that? Why isn’t she in a studio? I used to do the same thing when I would go wandering around Manhattan, taking photographs of store windows. I was more obsessed with the details in the edges as I composed the scene. In big screen movies I look away from the main characters, will I see Alfred Hitchcock’s back as he moves around a corner? I’m forever amazed looking at my daughter Hilary’s photos – she’s sold many, I need to write about the one of Nora Ephron, used by Frank Rich in New York Magazine – when I look at the edges, always seemingly effortlessly composed.

I think I need to add this to my list of obsessions. Might be in my list of topics as well.

(14) The Power of Detail
Read this chapter again and again. The opening paragraph is all you really need to read…

(15) Baking a Cake
You have all the ingredients, you need to put them together, you must add the heat and energy of your heart. You need both the ingredients and the heat and energy coming from your heart for writing.
Be totally into your writing… writing does writing.

(16) Living Twice
Writers go back outside in the rain with notebook and pen…

(17) Listening
Writing is 90% listening.

(18) Know your goal, stay with it.

(19) Trust your own voice

(20) It’s time to sip some wine!

Wm initials